The Academy Must Make Changes Starting Today #OscarNoms

Around the time that Napster was deep in litigation with every music label and Metallica I wrote a paper about the problems that plagued the music industry. I wrote that whomever figures out how to conquer Mp3’s will undoubtedly change the landscape of the music industry, forever. Not long too long after that, came the iPod and iTunes and a new path was forged.

Right now the film industry is in a similar position.“The ways it’s always been” is not working. Talented POC and Women are not seeing the opportunities behind the camera, in every facet compared to White Men. They are also not being recognized for the outstanding work they do produce. They are not rewarded with lucrative movie franchises  (Elizabeth Banks first time directing Pitch Perfect 2 and 69 million dollar opening with a 35 million dollar budget) and because of the cost of going to a theater to see a movie, people are not going to see as many movies like they used to. The consequence is indie movies aren’t being  released to as many theaters.

Award Season was once a special time to celebrate all of these movies, and wet the appetite of the movie goer, to see movies they normally would not.

There are many detractors from this, the movies that are generally considered award worthy are released November-January ( During the Holiday period when the average American is strapped) So the varying members of the academy and other guilds have the distinct pleasure of getting “Screeners”. So they get to watch every movie that these studios send out, (are supposed to) and vote accordingly.

It seems lately the MPAA, The Studios and some Film Makers have such conniption about these films showing up on torrent sites that they are more interested in playing whack a mole that the screeners themselves (as in the case with The Hateful Eight) become the story, instead of the intended Oscar Campaign. In my humble opinion something that is not favorable on the film maker.

While I am not advocating piracy, I do think that the people who have enormous interest in the screeners are not out to take money from Studios or Film Makers. They are people who build buzz, they are people who talk about movies with others. When the Academy Awards come on, these are some of the very few people outside of the Academy who have seen almost all the movies nominated. The only skin they have in the game, is talking up the movies that they enjoyed. People who use torrent sites also tend to spend 30% more on entertainment  products than the average consumer. I have seen no conscious effort in taking the Napster lesson to heart here. Instead of playing Whack a Mole with individuals, the MPAA could be finding those who think outside the box on how to change a failing formula into the next iPod/iTunes solution.

Ultimately this solution will help some and hurt some, I realize that theaters hemorrhage money out the gate, and if the industry really wants to help them stay alive they need to work out a different financial deal with them. If I have a 70 inch 4k television and surround sound I am not going to be inclined to spend 60 dollars on concessions after paying 20 bucks a ticket to see a movie. This is unsustainable. As it is, the film industry has set it up so that only those which have reasonable certainty to be blockbusters are widely released and I truly believe that people are getting bored with that formula.

This is just my first piece about the disappointing award season so far, but believe me I have much more to say..



About GeekGirlRising 122 Articles
PA, Film Tech, APOC, Locations Overflow for IATSE Local 480. Living In New Mexico. I have been a TV Critic for NM Entertainment Magazine. Documentary Film Maker. Writer. Researcher. Lover of All Things Geek. Striving to promote gender equality in STEM related fields and in the Media. Film Nerd, Comic Book Fiend, TV Addict, Gamer.


  1. Well worded & true. Lots of films don’t get wide releases or are released after the awards which leaves the person clueless about the nominated films. Using torrent sites isn’t a crime but selling that content to make money is. Torrent is a great tool for screeners to be released on for people desperately in need of wanting to watch the nominated films instead of waiting for the film to release where there will undoubtedly be cuts thanks to the censor board limiting the ability to appreciate the content as a whole

    • Well, using torrent sites isn’t illegal that’s true. But the MPAA likes to sit in swarms and grab IP addresses and threatening letters to an ISP who can terminate your service. I mean seriously Quentin Tarantino honestly thinks that the reason that the hateful eight was almost worst opening (grindhouse being the first) ever for him was because a screener showed up online. Instead of promoting his movie, he was chastising the group of people who were posting screeners and also pissing off the police union. I know that a lot of Oscar Worthy movies had screeners that wern’t widely sent out or they tried to do viewings instead. It’s not how things work. That is how people pick and choose which films they will likely go vote for. Its how movies likes Straight Outta Compton, Chi-Raq, Beasts of No Nation– I could go on and on don’t get the appreciation they rightly deserve.

      • Agreed. But even though the torrent site released the torrent, they pulled it down once they realized that a lot of films they put up hadn’t had releases yet. Yeah, people have to use proxy addresses to avoid those complications. But what about not getting access to those movies? Torrent is the next best bet. A lot of people write brilliant review for those movies and are guaranteed to pick up DVDs or download from places like the iTunes store or stream on Netflix.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.